|
AVKO's Test That
Demonstrates the Simple
Principle:
Words
Containing Phonic
Patterns
Never
Systematically Taught
Are More Difficult to Read or
Spell than Those Words that
Contain
Phonic Patterns
Normally Taught
or Encountered in Whole Language
Classrooms
During the First Three Years of
School. |
Which word in each pair of words
is more likely to be misspelled or too
difficult for a student to read?
-
1.
|
-
painter
-
partial
|
-
2.
|
-
precious
-
pretends
|
-
3.
|
-
chateaux
-
churches
|
-
4.
|
-
booklets
-
boutique
|
-
5.
|
-
mechanized
-
meaningful
|
-
6.
|
-
unions
-
unsafe
|
-
7.
|
-
mistakes
-
missions
|
-
8.
|
-
petites
-
pecking
|
-
9.
|
-
collected
-
collusion
|
-
10.
|
-
spending
-
specials
|
Prediction: Even though each
word pair has the same number of letters
and syllables and begin with exactly the
same two letters, the mode and the
median score will be 100% correct. The
mean will be close to 90% correct!
Reason? We all intuitively know that we
haven't been taught or haven't been
systematically exposed to the phonic
patterns in one of each pair of words.
Believe it or not, all the words below
are phonically regular!
Answers:
1. partial, 2. precious, 3.
chateaux, 4. boutique, 5. mechanized, 6.
unions,
7. missions, 8. petites, 9. collusion,
10. specials.
Reasons: 1.
The word partial
contains two phonic patterns not
systematically taught. The first
is the ti digraph for the /sh/ phoneme.
The second is the ending -al that rather
than rhyme with pal and gal and Sal it
is the same as the -el in nickel, the
-le in pickle, the -ol in pistol, the -il
in pencil, and the -ul in mogul.
Note that there is not one single word
in the English language in which the
ending "shul" sound is spelled "shul."
The sound "shul" is either spelled tial
as in initial or cial as in
crucial.
2. The word
precious
has two phonic patterns not
systematically taught. The first
is the ci digraph for the /sh/ phoneme.
The second is the ending -ous that
rather than rhyme with mouse rhymes with
us.
3. The word
chateaux
contains three phonic patterns not
systematically taught. The first
is the ch digraph for the /sh/ phoneme.
The second is the eau vowel trigraph
used for the long o sound. The
third is the x which may or may not be
pronounced as a /z/ phoneme indicating a
plural.
4. The word
boutique
contains three phonic patterns not
systematically taught. The first
is the ou having the "oo" sound as in
boo rather the the "ow!" sound
as in out. The second is
the letter i having the sound of a long
e. The third is the ending -que
that has the sound of the phoneme /k/.
Thus unique rhymes with
peek and peak and, of
course, pique.
5. The word
mechanized
contains only two spelling patterns not
systematically taught. The first
is the ch digraph having the sound of
the phoneme /k/. The second is the
letter a as a schwa.
6. The word
unions
has three spelling patterns not
systematically taught. The first
is the "invisible" y. The very
first phoneme has no letter for it.
Normally the letters un are sounded as
"un" as in unable, under, unless, until,
etc. But in the word unions
the letters un are used to represent the
"yoon" sound. The second is the
letter i being used as the consonant y
for the phoneme /y/. The third
pattern is the ending -on that rhymes
with fun. Note that in our
language the "yun" sound is never
spelled yun. It might be nice if
we could spell onion as "unyun" and
union as "yoonyun" but we just don't.
We like to consider the letters i and y
as identical twins that just love to
switch identities. The y can sound
as a long i as in try or a
short i as in gym. The
letter i can sound as the consonant y in
senior and onion.
7. The word
missions
has two patterns not systematically
taught. The first is the ssi
trigraph for the /sh/ phoneme. The
second is the ending -on pronounced to
rhyme with fun. Note, there are
four common spellings of the sound
"shun:" tion as in nation, cion as
in suspicion, sion as in tension, and
ssion as in passion.
8. The word
petites
has only one pattern not systematically
taught. This pattern is the letter
i having the sound of the long e.
Petites rhymes with beets and beats.
9. The word
collusion
has two patterns not systematically
taught. The
first is the si digraph for the /zh/
phoneme. Note that although the /zh/
phoneme is used as "zh" in dictionary
diacritics, there is not one word in the
English language that spells the /zh/
phoneme with the letters zh! The
third pattern is the ending
-on pronounced to rhyme
with fun. The "zhun" sound is
spelled either sion
as in vision or
sian as in Asian.
10. The word
specials
has two spelling patterns not
systematically taught. The first
is the ci digraph for the /sh/ phoneme.
The second is the ending -al that rather
than rhyme with pal and gal and Sal it
rhymes with the -el in nickel, the -le
in pickle, the -ol in pistol, the -il in
pencil, and the -ul in mogul. Note
that there is not one single word in the
English language in which the ending "shul"
sound is spelled "shul." The sound
"shul" is either spelled tial as in
initial or cial as in crucial.
If you would like
a listing of patterns not systematically
taught, we will send you a copy of
The Mechanics of English
Spelling if you will
send us $1.00 for the postage.
Just request it in a letter to the AVKO
Foundation, 3084 Willard Road, Suite
W, Birch Run MI, 48415. Or you can
visit our web page
Essential Patterns Seldom Systematically
Taught.
If you still are a
Doubting Thomas, we challenge you to
make a spot check on one of your
students who is reading somewhere in the
vicinity of 3.5 and have him/her read an
article from a newspaper or magazine.
Mark the words missed. If you
don't quite understand which patterns
are taught and which aren't, send the
results to me and I'll mark each word
missed with a notation as to the phonic
pattern that is or isn't taught.
If you send me the article that you
choose to use, I can mark the words
beforehand that contain the patterns not
systematically taught and you can then
easily judge whether or not your student
missed 3 out of 4 of those words and
whether 3 out of every 4 words he/she
missed contained one or more of those
patterns. You can do this by
eMailing
info@avko.org
If
you have comments about this website,
you are encouraged to e-mail
DonMcCabe@aol.com. We
appreciate any comments that will help
us make this website even more useful.
- Call Toll
Free: 1-866-AVKO-612
Fax: (810) 686-1101
E-mail: Webmaster:
avkoemail@aol.com
or Write:
Don McCabe, Research Director
- AVKO
Educational Research Foundation
3084 Willard Road, Suite W
Birch Run, MI 48415-9404
All donations are greatly
appreciated. If you would like to
support our mission which is to raise
the level of literacy to the point where
the words, illiteracy, phonemic
awareness, learning disabilities,
dysgraphia, family literacy, adult
literacy, and illegible handwriting will
no longer have relevance, please mail
your tax-deductible check (in U.S.
dollars) to The AVKO Educational
Research Foundation, 3084 Willard
Road, Suite W, Birch Run, MI 48415-9404.
The AVKO Foundation is recognized by the
IRS as a 501(C)3 publicly supported
organization working with teachers,
parents, tutors, and homeschooling
parents, publishing materials developed
by its research, and providing free
daily tutoring at its local reading
clinic.
|